Diskussion:ISO TC 215 - ISO TS 13582: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen

Aus Hl7wiki
Wechseln zu: Navigation, Suche
(Comments received from Olivier Dubuisson 20101006)
 
K (1 Version)
(kein Unterschied)

Version vom 7. Februar 2011, 13:50 Uhr

Excerpt from Email discussions

20100510

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Telco discussions

20100428: Ted Klein, Sylvia Thun, Kai Heitmann

  • Discussed OID categories, reflected now in the correspondig sections of the document.

20100430: Ted Klein, Kai Heitmann

  • Will set up wiki access for Ted Klein, John Larmouth, Olivier Dubuisson. Sylvia and Kai already have access. This allows collaborate editing.
  • Kai apologizes for having this in a German environment. But he makes use of several Wiki-Templates. Can move later to another place, but for now it remains here.
  • Discussed: classes of the communication model
    • ThisOIDregistry
      • gets a desc
      • card 1..* for organization
      • card 1..* for OID
    • OID
      • card 1..1 for registrationAuthority
    • RegistrationAuthority
      • delete validTime
      • card 0..1 for person
    • ResponsibleAuthority
      • make clear def, it is resp for the object identified, not for the OID itself
    • SubmittingAuthority
      • card 1..1 for person
    • Person
      • gets a coded roleCode
    • Description
      • constraint: at least one Description with lanuguage code EN (english)
      • discussed required subsections like "versioning" or "intellectual properties" as part of the desc. TBD more
    • Link
      • merged with Reference class - rationale: Link links to objects with different semantics, Reference links to things with same semantics (see description)
    • HistoryAnnotation
      • kind of log book, records the changes (of anything associated with this OID) over time
    • Reference
      • merged with Link class
      • get's type of "link" coded as linkType

20100503: Ted Klein, Kai Heitmann

  • OID class
    • symbolicName: use next symbolicName also Secondary Arc Identifier
    • add title, i.e. the unrestricted name / title / very short description of the OID
    • add a sort key as ST 0..1 O or 1..1 M to provide a sorting mechanism. In HL7 reg it is mandatory, and we should seek for defaulting the sort key. Decision: make mandatory (with default suggestions).
    • creationDate has to be 1..1 M, it is now: the date of entry of the OID in the registry
    • applicationDate can be dropped, any information around application goes to HistoryAnnotation
    • association submittingAuthority should be 1..*, it should be possible to indicate primary, secondary, on behalf of submitters. This is reflected in RoleStatus (in several classes) which should be RoleType.
    • lastModifiedDate: drop, goed to HistoryAnnotation
    • realm: drop, should be an AdditionalProperty instance
  • RoleStatus = RoleType
    • should cover primary, secondary, on behalf of, contact person
  • V2 AssigingAuthority (HL7 v2 HD data type), is missing or not. TDB how to support this if at all.
  • Permissions discussed:
    • authoritative vs non-authoritative answers (source of truth); for OIDs for which the reporting registry is the registring authority, it may answer authoritative
    • HL7: see vs updating vs creating an entry
      • meta control information: OID property dependent of classes of the OID
    • actually this is part of the maintanance NWIP and a business need of a registry, but it is not communicated
  • Discussed: OIDcategory
  • Discussed: ObjectType

Ideas

  • It would be nice to have a reference installation based on publicly available SQL server with web interface. --K. Heitmann 13:07, 3. Mai 2010 (UTC)

Comments

Gathered through the first (internal = DE, AT, and CH) ballot rounds. Sorry for the German. Additional comments from ISO NWIP proces.

Kommentar Stefan Sabutsch (AT)

Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar

Kommentar Tony Schaller (CH)

Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar

Kommentar Frank Oemig (DE)

Vorlage:Kommentar

Comments (on the data model) received from Canada 20100929

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar

Comments received from Olivier Dubuisson 20101006

Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar

Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar


Vorlage:Kommentar

Comments received from Kai Heitmann 20101001

Vorlage:Kommentar